Open Always
Email: Call Now! +1-315 515-4588
Open Always
Email: Call Now! +1-315 515-4588

Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint

This sample paper on (Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint) was uploaded by one our contributors and does not necessarily reflect how our professionals write our papers. If you would like this paper removed from our website, please contact us via our Contact Us Page.

A Database of over Million Scholarly Resources. Start your Search Now

Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint

The knowledge on standpoint theory is critical in analyzing inter-subjective communication. Standpoint theorists underline the use of a naturalistic concept of knowing to analyze facts. Two standpoints that philosophers deal with are the modern standpoint and the traditional standpoint. The modern standpoint (or modern square of opposition) is usually based on the Boolean standpoint to assess validity of propositions. The square of opposition permits readers to analyze the relationship that exist between propositions. On the other hand, the traditional standpoint (or the traditional square) is based on the Aristotelian standpoint, which revolves around deduction of logic. The Boolean and Aristotelian standpoints differ from each other in terms of universal proposition concerning existing things.

The traditional standpoint implies that all universal propositions indicate existing things. Just like the modern standpoint, the traditional standpoint entails arrangement of lines that exemplifies logically necessary relations, which involve four kinds of definite propositions.  Aristotelian standpoint identifies universal propositions concerning existing things as having existential imports (Hurley 227). For instance,

All bears are brown.

The above statement indicates that, in reality, bears exist. This implies that Aristotelian standpoint has existential import. While interpreting Aristotle standpoint, every claim is supposed to either confirm or refute a single predicate in a single subject. The word ‘universal’ in Aristotle standpoint literary means ‘whole,’ hence, its opposite should be ‘particular.’

Aristotelian standpoint recognizes that the traditional square sustains more presumptions than the modern square. The representation of Aristotelian standpoint is characterized by the four relations as follows:

  • Contradictory – opposite truth value
  • Contrary – at least one is false
  • Sub contrary – at least one is true
  • Sub alternation – truth flows downward while falsity flows upwards

Boolean standpoint does not offer support for universal claims as having existential import. For example,

All lions are hungry.

This statement does not indicate that lions really exist. Hence, the statement lacks existential import. It is through universal propositions that the Boolean standpoint becomes relevant. Adopting the Boolean standpoint implies that a person can ignore any evidence concerning the existence conveyed by universal statements.

The Boolean standpoint is represented through four categorical proposals in a Venn diagram. A Venn diagram entails an array of overlapping circles where each circle signifies the class indicated by a term within the categorical proposition (Hurley 208). Since every categorical proposition incorporate two terms, a single categorical proposition must have two overlapping circles as illustrated below in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Venn Diagram

The members of categories expressed by each term are indicated inside each circle. Thus, members that are indicated where the circles overlaps are perceived to belong to both groups while those outside the circles do not belong to any group.

The emergence of Modern Square of Opposition happens when there is a contradictory relation. Contradictory relations imply that there exist opposite truth values in every proposition. For instance, a statement that “All bats are mammals” contradicts another statement that “Some bats cannot be mammals.” According to Hurley, if two suggestions are related through the contradictory relation, then they automatically have opposite truth value (211). Figure 2 below illustrates Modern Square of Opposition.

Figure 2: The Modern Square of Opposition

Adopting either modern standpoint or traditional standpoint makes an individual to accept ground rules that are utilized in interpreting the significance of universal propositions. An individual can opt for either standpoint while arguing about categorical propositions. Any categorical syllogism or reasoning that goes against the four relation characteristics is void from the Aristotelian standpoint. One of the implications of existential import is that if this import is denied for a universal proposition, then the relations within the square becomes unacceptable since they are no more valid (Chatti and Schang 104). The Boolean standpoint is simpler than Aristotelian standpoint due to its closeness to existence. Aristotelian standpoint attracts existential implications.

In the traditional standpoint, a proposition is perceived as a spoken assertion, rather than the meaning of assertion, as demonstrated through the modern standpoint. For Aristotelian standpoint, every affirmation has to correspond with a negation. The confirmation and the negation have to oppose each other since one of the statements is deemed to be true while the other is false. In modern standpoint, it is logical to highlight the opposition of a given claim, instead of insisting that each claim holds several different opposites. Contradictory relations indicate that Boolean standpoint can support Aristotelian standpoint in opposing a given statement.

Both traditional and modern standpoints are fundamental in inferring the truth value concerning a proposition that has existential implication. Assuming that a subject term cannot be indicated by an empty set, the Aristotle standpoint incorporates four relations that include contradictory, contrary, sub contrary, as well as implication. The Boolean standpoint diverges from the Aristotelian standpoint in regard to how it construes the existence of individuals in universal statements. In the Boolean standpoint, the only rational relation is the contradictory connection. Contrariwise, accepting the Boolean standpoint may lead to ignoring evidences that the universal statement could have held about existence. While the Boolean standpoint illustrates ‘closed’ proposition of existence, the Aristtelian standpoint indicates ‘openness’ to existence.










Works Cited

Chatti, Saloua, and Fabien Schang. “The Cube, The Square And The Problem Of Existential Import.” History & Philosophy of Logic 34.2 (2013): 101-132. Academic Search Premier. Web. 16 Apr. 2016.

Hurley, Patrick J. A Concise Introduction to Logic. Boston, MA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 2012. Print.

Sharing is: CARING

Are you looking for homework writing help? Click on Order Now button below to Submit your assignment details.

Homework Writing Help
We Can Help you with this Assignment right now!
Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint

Are you looking for homework writing help on (Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint)?Well, you can either use the sample paper provided to write your paper or you could contact us today for an original paper. If you are looking for an assignment to submit, then click on ORDER NOW button or contact u today. Our Professional Writers will be glad to write your paper from scratch.




We ensure that assignment instructions are followed, the paper is written from scratch. If you are not satisfied by our service, you can either request for refund or unlimited revisions for your order at absolutely no extra pay. Once the writer has completed your paper, the editors check your paper for any grammar/formatting/plagiarism mistakes, then the final paper is sent to your email.

Privacy| Confidentiality

Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint

We do not share your personal information with any company or person. We have also ensured that the ordering process is secure; you can check the security feature in the browser. For confidentiality purposes, all papers are sent to your personal email. If you have any questions, contact us any time via email, live chat or our phone number.

Our Clients Testimonials

  • I appreciate help on the assignment. It was hard for me but am good to go now

    Impact of pollution on Environment
  • Am happy now having completed the very difficult assignment

    Creative Message Strategies
  • Your writer did a fine job on the revisions. The paper is now ok

    Ethics: Theory and Practice
  • The paper was so involving but am happy it is done. Will reach you with more assignments

    Title: Privatization in or of America
  • I expected perfection in terms of grammar and I am happy. Lecturer is always on our head but was pleased with my paper. Once again, thanks a lot

    Title: Bundaberg Inquiry
  • The paper looks perfect now, thank to the writer

    Health Care Systems
  • You helped me complete several other tasks as you handled paper. wonna thank you

    Critique Paper on Political Change

Related Articles

Sample Essay on Modern Standpoint from Traditional Standpoint

Analyze the Nursing Roles in providing Comprehensive care in a Variety of Community Health Settings

Community Settings This week’s graded topics relate to the following Course Outcomes (COs). CO3: Plan prevention and population-focused interventions for vulnerable populations using professional clinical judgment and evidence-based practice. (POs...
Read More

Case Study Assignment on Ethical Issues in Asia-Pacific business

Case study assignment on Ethical Issues in Asia-Pacific business For this assignment, students will write a case study report in 2,000 words based on a case identified with circumstance or...
Read More

Sample Report Paper on The proposed reward system and strategy for the big city university

A good reward system should motivate workers. It should also attract and retain the same workers. On the contrary, a bad reward system does not do either of these things....
Read More

Management of PCOS through Homoeopathy-A case report

Introduction PCOS is the acronym for Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome. It is the most common endocrine disorder of women in their reproductive period manifested by irregular menstrual cycles and polycystic ovaries,...
Read More

Get more from us…

Would you like this sample paper to be sent to your email or would you like to receive weekly articles on how to write your assignments? You can simply send us your request on how to write your paper and we will email you a free guide within 24-36 hours. Kindly subscribe below!

Email Address: